Gender and Politics
7:25 pm May 22nd, 2008Like many people my age, I voted for Obama this year. But while I didn’t vote for the female candidate, it’s not because I think we’ve reached some sort of post-feminist utopia. I’m not choosing any candidate based solely on demographic factors, but I don’t think these factors are irrelevant to the effects a candidate’s election will have or the way a candidate is presented and perceived.
I’ve heard some of my male peers say that Clinton “wasn’t a good feminist candidate” because she gained political power partly through her association with her husband; I’ve also heard them say that it doesn’t matter whether we elect a woman president, because there are already female governors, senators, and world leaders in other countries. But I think it does matter — I think there’s a lot to be gained in terms of public perception from having a woman elected president of the United States. We still live in a country where men shout “Iron my shirt!” at an accomplished professional woman — if they think that’s funny, they don’t get it, and the day we do elect a woman president is one day closer to people like that “getting it”.
The New York Times describes some ways in which Clinton’s gender may have affected the race:
Mrs. Clinton’s supporters point to a nagging series of slights: the fixation on her clothes, even her cleavage; chronic criticism that her voice is shrill; calls for her to exit the race; and most of all, the male commentators in the news media who, they argue, were consistently tougher on her than on Mr. Obama.
The reasons I have for voting for Obama don’t make me blind to these factors — I very much do think that Clinton’s campaign has been presented differently because of her gender and that she’s had to contend with obstacles and perceptions that are never an issue for a male politician. This primary has been framed as a divisive, either-or situation, but it’s a false choice. Obama supporters and Clinton supporters are painted as people with no common ground, when in fact most of us agree about a great deal. Just because I ended up preferring Obama doesn’t mean that I don’t recognize the challenges Clinton has endured solely because of her gender or that I don’t see the value in having a woman president for the sake of having a woman president.
